Pete Kendall's Socio Times: A Socionomic Commentary

Higher gas pump and heating costs damped economic growth and consumer spending in September for the worst slowdown in shopping in 25 years, a government report said yesterday.

Even the White House's own man spoke frankly about the problem, a departure from the administration's optimistic spin in recent months. In a Detroit speech, Treasury Secretary John Snow said our higher fuel prices are reducing purchasing power, and have an "adverse psychological effect" on consumers, as well as hurting profits of companies.

U.S. consumer spending dropped for the second consecutive month — the first time for back-to-back months of such a slowdown in 15 years.
New York Post, November 1, 2005

The Threat Behind Consumer Spending
Hurricanes can bury a lot of things, but don't let them bury a very important nugget in Monday's personal income and spending report: the consumer fell off a spending cliff in August and September!

Spending on durable goods (remember? Big-ticket items built to last three years or more?) fell by 2.4 percent in September after plunging 8.9 percent in August, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, the economics arm of the Commerce Department.
CNN/Money, October 31, 2005
Bumpy road for GM, Ford
Weak October sales for the two biggest automakers are a clear sign their problems aren't going away.

As bad as October sales are expected to be for General Motors Corp. and Ford Motor Co., the real problem for the nation's two largest automakers may still lie ahead.
CNN/Money, October 31, 2005

U.K. October Retail Sales
Decline for Eighth Month
U.K. retail sales fell for an eighth month in October, a survey of 128 companies showed.

Forty-two percent of the retailers surveyed said sales fell from a year earlier, while 24 percent said they rose, the Confederation of British Industry said today in London. That gave a balance of minus 18 percentage points, after September's minus 24, which was the lowest since the report began in 1983.
Bloomberg, November 1, 2005

April 2007
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30          

« Previous | Main Page | Next »

Consumers are buying less.
By: Pete Kendall, November 1, 2005
Since this is a third-wave decline for consumer confidence, a downside explosion that alters the face of the U.S. economy should occur over the next few months.
The Elliott Wave Financial Forecast, May 2005

All the reports want to pin the blame for the consumer's slackening appetite for goods and services on the rise in oil and gas prices, but oil and gas have returned to their levels of July. Still, consumer sentiment continues to move lower, as forecast in earlier issues of The Elliott Wave Financial Forecast. As the reference below from September 2004 shows, the pricing and demand for Ford and GM cars back in 2004 car prices was one of the early tip-offs. The article above notes that car sales are also down in October despite a downside reversal that has returned oil and gas prices to their July level; this suggests that  the "threat behind consumer spending" is not over. As a matter of fact, it scope is broadening . The last article above notes the emergence of a rather virulent strain in England. Pretty soon there should be no hiding its spread in all directions.

consumer shakes

Additional References

EWFF, October 2005
Back in the summer of 2004 when car buyers held out for discounts, The Elliott Wave Financial Forecast identified the development as “bad news for car companies and the overall economy.” The decision to wait for lower prices last July was a big deal because, as EWI has continually noted, deflation is a state of mind, and “a willingness to forestall purchases is one of its primary attributes.” Early this year, U.S. car companies pulled themselves out of a renewed sales slump by selling new cars and trucks to the public at the same low price offered to employees. After saying the program would end in August, GM extended it another month. But sales of new cars and trucks fell anyway, by 16.6% from the same month a year ago. The decline was attributed to “consumer fatigue with employee pricing deals.” In September, after initially extending the employee-pricing scheme, GM abandoned it for “everyday” low prices.

The same “fatigue” is registering in Wal-Mart’s stock price, which is at its lowest level in four years, as well as plunging consumer confidence, which just suffered its biggest point decline since the start of the 1990 recession. In another sign of surrender, credit card delinquencies rose to a record high of 4.81% in the second quarter. Our stock market section covers a host of different areas in which the free-spirited ways of the bull market are giving way to the sobering influence of a third wave of Primary degree. These declines signal its arrival in the consumer, who will probably complete the transition from impulsive spendthrift to cautious tightwad faster than most can fathom. Changes like the newly-restrictive bankruptcy laws will kick in and contribute to the coming new conservatism.

The U.S. President called for consumers to “pitch in” and avoid “a trip that’s not essential.” He is encouraging the White House staff to turn off lights, printers, copiers and computers when they leave the office, scaling back on his motorcade and cramming more reporters into fewer press vans. Presidents always fail as economic cheerleaders in bear markets. Nixon and Carter both resorted to conservation measures in the decline of the 1970s. The exhortations of Hoover and Roosevelt in Supercycle IV, a bear market that lasted through 1949 in inflation adjusted terms, is a better parallel. With consumer spending on food, housing, clothing and automobiles down 40% to 65% from 1929 to 1933, they did everything they could to get consumers buying again. Once the economy turns down, it probably won’t be long before Bush’s turn-out-the-lights effort gets cast aside for a 1930s style “get-out-there-and-spend” program.

 EWFF, May 2005
Reporting from Seoul, Stephen Roach of Morgan Stanley writes, “Here in Asia, they have only one question for me: How’s the American consumer? Most react with sheer disbelief when I even dare to mention the possible demise of the American consumer.” On his Asian swing, Roach is telling clients of a mismatch between what consumers earn or have in the bank and what they are spending. “Believe it or not, one client out here was so angry with me he actually tore my chart of the vanishing personal saving rate into tiny little pieces. Asians want to believe that the income-short, saving-short, overly indebted American consumer will never stop spending.” On the contrary, he will probably soon be a net seller.

In finance, desperation and hope are an explosive combination. Violent disappointment is the usual result, and this chart of consumer sentiment is a picture of the fuse being lit on one of the world’s larget bombs. EWFF has tracked the consumer’s arc through the nether reaches of extreme optimism since shortly before the Dow’s all-time high in 2000. In January 2004, when sentiment popped back above the “fateful 100 line,” EWFF identified the burst as a sure sign that a “knock-out punch is still ahead.” The key to that forecast was the 5-3 form of the action since the all-time highs. As it turns out, sentiment’s three-wave rally was complete at that time. The chart at right also reveals a close tie between consumers’ vitality and stock prices. Both the Dow and consumer confidence peaked in January 2000 and bottomed in March 2003, along with the European stocks and many U.S. averages adjusted for dollar weakness. The March peak for stocks has been accompanied by a decline of almost 10% in the confidence index. Since this is a third-wave decline for consumer confidence, a downside explosion that alters the face of the U.S. economy should occur over the next few months.

EWFF, September 2004
With retail stocks breaking through their 200-day moving average and Wal-Mart and the International Council of Shopping Centers ratcheting down sales forecasts, it is clear that consumers’ behavior is reflecting a deflationary psychology. Economists’ complete blindness to this event is apparent in stories about a July uptick in consumer spending. “The American consumer is back,” said the New York Post on Tuesday. After falling 0.2 percent in June, personal consumer spending rose 0.8 percent in July. “The easing of consumers’ restraint is welcome news for the economy,” said The New York Times. A few economists started to sweat over consumers’ “sudden stinginess, but the recovery of consumer spending – which accounts for about two-thirds of economic activity – has rekindled some faith in the economy’s staying power.”

It’s true, there is a “new spring in consumers’ stride,” but a closer look at the monthly spending numbers reveals an important new development that takes the shine off of the consensus assessment of economists. Most of the June drop in sales of durable goods was from a fall in auto sales, and virtually all of the July’s rebound was also due to cars. The head of market and industry analysis at General Motors explained that the July pop in sales was due to the “summer sell-down,” when car makers offer deals to clear the lots. “Consumers are timing their purchases more. That has changed.” This development is bad news for car companies and the overall economy. As EWI has long noted, deflation is a state of mind. Consumers’ decision to wait for lower July prices is a sign that this mindset is taking hold, as a willingness to forestall purchases is one of its primary attributes.

Post a comment

(you may use HTML tags for style)

April 16, 2007
Does Imus Cancellation Radio a Bear Market Signal?
read more
April 12, 2007
One Small Coffee Shop Uprising for Starbucks, a Grande Leap for Labor
read more
April 11, 2007
Dazzling Finish: Cars Bring Once-Boring Shades To Life
read more
April 10, 2007
T in T-Line Stands for Top
read more
April 5, 2007
The Fight for a Free Vermont? Must be a Big, Big Turn
read more


HOME | WHAT IS SOCIO TIMES? | CONTRIBUTE | SEARCH    Copyright © 2024 | Privacy Policy | Report Site Issues